Ex-FIFA referee claims World Cup red card drama was wrong after compensation claim

Former FIFA and Premier League referee Keith Hackett has claimed that Themba Zwane should NOT have been sent off in South Africa’s defeat to Mexico.

The two sides came together on Thursday evening in the World Cup’s curtain raiser in Mexico City. It could not have gone much worse for the African nation, with Julian Quinones giving the hosts the lead in the ninth minute. Yaya Sithole was then dismissed for the denial of a goalscoring opportunity, with Mexico taking advantage through Raul Jimenez, who scored his side’s second.

Things then got even worse for South Africa, with Zwane also sent off for "serious foul play" against Roberto Alvarado, with the midfielder appearing to strike his opponent with his arm. He initially stayed on the pitch, only for the referee to change his mind following a VAR review.

But Hackett reckons Zwane was hard done by, arguing that the incident did not meet the criteria for serious foul play. He told Football Insider: "Whilst the red card issued might be deemed to be 'soft', the South African player used his hand/arm in an illegal manner, opening up the VAR intervention.

"My view is that this red card did not meet the criteria for serious foul play. At most, the action was reckless, and a yellow card would have been appropriate."

The red cards were not quite finished there. Mexico’s Cesar Montes was also given an early bath after being sent off in stoppage time.

Hackett’s comments are not the first time that he has weighed in on the refereeing controversy at the World Cup. Somalian official Omar Artan was denied entry in the USA ahead of the tournament and speaking after that decision, Hackett claimed that FIFA should compensate the referee with the fee that he would have received.

Themba Zwane

Themba Zwane was sent off for an alleged slap(Image: Getty Images)

He said: "This appears to be so unfair, depriving a young referee of the opportunity to officiate at a World Cup. The pathway to the top is incredibly difficult, and this referee has developed a career that has seen him meet the challenges and rise to the elite level.

"I am sure that his family and federation will be so disappointed. Referees expected to earn in the region of $100,000 (£74,630). So, I hope that FIFA, who have failed in supporting his case, will make a discretionary payment of $100,000 to him and his family."

FIFA will be hopeful of navigating away from more controversy as the World Cup continues on Friday. Group B gets underway with Canada’s clash with Bosnia and Herzegovina, while the USA take on Paraguay in their Group D opener overnight.

Read Next Article